Cheatham school board unanimously halts exploration of closing Pegram Elementary

After weeks of uncertainty and mounting concern among South Cheatham families, the Cheatham County School Board unanimously voted to stop exploring the closure of Pegram Elementary School on Nov. 5.

Share
Cheatham school board unanimously halts exploration of closing Pegram Elementary

After weeks of uncertainty and mounting concern among South Cheatham families, the Cheatham County School Board unanimously voted to stop exploring the closure of Pegram Elementary School on Nov. 5.

The decision came after nine people, including parents and Pegram Elementary Principal Sarah Spain, spoke against the proposed merger during a public forum. Their comments were followed by an impassioned debate among board members about the process, the school’s future and the district’s declining enrollment.

District 3 Representative Dale McCarver, who made the motion to stop the closure exploration, said the discussion had moved too quickly and left the community feeling as though the school’s future was already in jeopardy.

“Not only are we going down the wrong road, we're going down the wrong road 180 miles an hour,” McCarver said, criticizing the way the proposal had been introduced and the limited time residents had to respond.

He said Pegram has a strong principal, staff and supportive community, and argued that the district should focus on promoting the school and increasing enrollment rather than considering its closure.

“I will make a motion to stop the exploration of the closing Pegram Elementary School,” he said.

The motion was seconded and ultimately passed unanimously.

The vote followed a week of concern after the school board began examining the future of Pegram and Kingston Springs elementary schools on Oct. 29. The possibility of consolidation prompted strong reactions from families who feared Pegram Elementary could be closed.

During the November board discussion, members expressed different views about how to proceed. Some said the district still needed to examine enrollment trends and financial pressures, even if the specific exploration of closing Pegram ended.

One board member said Cheatham County schools have lost about 2,500 students since the turn of the century and argued that the district needs a broader strategy for addressing enrollment and finances.

The member said the district has been relying on its fund balance — essentially its savings — to maintain existing services, staffing and salaries as operating costs have increased. The member also pointed to declining birth rates and the need to understand why some families leave the district.

Another concern raised was the transition from fourth to fifth grade. Board members questioned why some families choose not to continue in the district at that point and said they wanted more information about those enrollment patterns.

The board member who supported continuing to gather information said the goal should be to find ways to keep South Cheatham schools open and financially sustainable, not to abandon the issue.

Focus turns to enrollment

Even as the board halted the exploration of closing Pegram Elementary, members discussed continuing efforts to improve enrollment.

One board member said the school’s future would depend in part on the community’s willingness to help promote it and encourage families to enroll. They called for a broader effort to share the strengths of Pegram Elementary with families throughout the county and beyond.

The board chair said she heard repeated suggestions from residents about ways to improve enrollment and said she would still like to see a committee focused on that work, potentially with efforts that could benefit schools throughout the district.

The discussion also underscored that enrollment concerns are not limited to Pegram. Board members described the issue as a districtwide challenge that will require a broader look at student trends, school finances and ways to attract and retain families.

The unanimous vote ends the board’s exploration of closing Pegram Elementary. It does not resolve the district’s wider enrollment and budget concerns, which members said will continue to require attention.